I've got something like 18 Stirling shave soaps and I have noticed a pattern: I prefer the ones that are based on nature rather than the ones based on colognes/aftershaves, etc.
And one of the really cool things Rod and Mandy do is include a free sample with orders and a while back I got a nice little sliver of Evergreen Forest. As soon as I opened the package, I knew I'd love it. And I did. So after a few months, I just had to order a refill size puck. This scent is intoxicating. It's like I'm transported into a dense forest. And in typical Stirling Soap fashion, it lathers beautifully and provides terrific cushion. My favorite Stirling scents are Barbershop, Bay Rum, Hot Apples Cider, Coniferous and now Evergreen Forest. It's one of those scents I can't conceive anyone not liking.